South Edmonton Location
- Home
- Conditions
- Meniscus tear
Meniscus tear treatment in Edmonton
Meniscus tear treatment in Edmonton that starts by telling a traumatic injury from a degenerative one, because the two are managed differently. For the gradual kind, randomised trials found structured exercise comparable to arthroscopic surgery, making it a first-line option rather than a consolation prize.
Book an appointment
What is a meniscus tear?
The menisci are two C-shaped wedges of cartilage that sit between the thigh bone and shin bone and spread load across the knee. Tears come in two broad kinds: traumatic tears, usually in younger people from a twisting injury, and degenerative tears, which develop gradually in middle age and later as the tissue changes. The distinction matters because they behave differently and are managed differently.
Traumatic and degenerative
A traumatic tear usually has a clear moment: a twist on a planted foot, often in sport, followed by pain on the joint line and swelling over the next day or so. It may occur alongside an ACL injury.
A degenerative tear usually has no moment at all. The knee becomes sore over weeks or months, often with a grumbling ache on the inside, stiffness after sitting, and discomfort squatting or twisting. Degenerative tears are extremely common findings on scans of people with no knee pain, and they usually sit alongside early osteoarthritic change rather than existing on their own.
What the research changed
Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy used to be one of the most commonly performed orthopaedic procedures. A series of randomised trials then compared it with exercise therapy, and with sham surgery, for degenerative tears — and outcomes were comparable at follow-up.
The practical consequence is that for a degenerative tear, a properly structured exercise program is a first-line option rather than a consolation prize, and clinical guidelines now reflect that.
When surgery is still the right conversation
Some presentations do point toward an orthopaedic opinion:
- A knee that is truly locked — it will not straighten fully, and will not be straightened passively
- Repeated genuine locking or catching that stops the knee mid-movement
- A traumatic tear in a younger knee, particularly a tear in the outer part of the meniscus where it has a blood supply and may be repairable
- A meniscus tear alongside an ACL tear that is being reconstructed
What treatment usually involves
Settling the irritable knee first: reducing the loads and ranges that flare it, restoring full extension, and getting the quadriceps working properly again.
Then progressive strengthening for the whole leg and a graded return to squatting, stairs and the activities that matter to you. Twelve weeks of consistent work is a fair trial before concluding anything.
Giving way, true locking, or a knee getting steadily worse are the signs to be reassessed rather than to push on.
Questions people ask
My scan shows a tear — doesn't that need fixing?
Not on its own. Meniscus tears are found on the scans of a large share of middle-aged and older people who have no knee pain. The finding on its own does not establish that it is causing your symptoms.
Can a meniscus tear heal?
The outer third has a blood supply and can heal, which is also why repairs there can work. The inner portion does not, so management there is about how the knee copes rather than about closing the tear.
What does locking actually mean?
A genuinely locked knee will not fully straighten, and cannot be straightened by someone else. Catching, clicking or a moment of hesitation is not the same thing, and it is worth being precise because true locking is one of the clearer reasons for a surgical opinion.
Does a meniscus tear need surgery?
Degenerative tears in adults over 40 generally do as well with exercise-based rehabilitation as with arthroscopy, and trials have shown that repeatedly. A locked knee that cannot fully straighten is the main exception, and that is assessed urgently.
Why does my knee click?
Clicking on its own, without pain or catching, is common and usually not from the meniscus. Painful catching or a knee that gives way is more meaningful. The assessment distinguishes noise from mechanical symptoms so you are not worrying about the wrong thing.
Can I keep cycling while it settles?
Usually, yes. Cycling loads the knee through a controlled range and is often the first activity people keep. The physiotherapist adjusts seat height and resistance so it helps rather than aggravates.
Book a knee assessment
Vertex Physiotherapy is at 6958 76 Ave NW #205, Edmonton, AB T6B 2R2. Call (825) 525-2852 or book online.